---
For a Brooklyn or NYC family seriously weighing this question, the answer isn't one number — it's several layers of financial relief stacking on top of each other. Taxes. Housing. Day-to-day costs. What you actually get in return.
Here's what that looks like, honestly and specifically.
New York is one of the most heavily taxed states in the country. New York City residents pay city income tax on top of state income tax — a combined burden that hits working families, retirees, and business owners hard every year.
Florida has no state income tax. Zero.
For a family with two working adults in a meaningful income bracket, this alone represents real, immediate annual savings. If you're retired and drawing from retirement accounts, the relief is even sharper — Florida doesn't tax pension income or Social Security either.
Property taxes in Florida are also structured differently. Yes, you pay property taxes, but the Homestead Exemption (available to Florida primary residents) reduces your assessed value, and the Save Our Homes cap limits how much that assessed value can increase year over year. For homeowners in Aventura, Hallandale Beach, or Boca Raton, this protection compounds meaningfully over time.
The estate tax picture matters too. New York has a state estate tax with a threshold that catches many middle-class families who don't consider themselves wealthy. Florida has no estate or inheritance tax at all.
This is where the conversation usually clicks for New York families.
In Brooklyn — Carroll Gardens, Park Slope, Flatbush — a two-bedroom co-op or condo in decent condition routinely lists in the high six or seven figures. Outdoor space is rare. Storage is an afterthought. Parking is a separate monthly expense on top of your mortgage.
In South Florida, that same budget buys substantially more. A three- or four-bedroom home with a backyard, a two-car garage, and room for a pool — in communities like Weston, Boynton Beach, or western Boca Raton — is a realistic outcome for families selling a Brooklyn property.
If coastal living is the draw, neighborhoods like Hollywood Beach, Hallandale Beach, and Sunny Isles Beach offer oceanside condos and walkable streets with a density that feels genuinely familiar to New Yorkers. Modern buildings, full amenities, doormen, security — at prices unthinkable at this proximity to water in New York.
Surfside and Bal Harbour attract buyers who want boutique and walkable. Aventura — arguably the most popular destination for Jewish families from Brooklyn and Queens — offers full suburban infrastructure with walkable shopping, a strong shul community, and easy highway access north and south.
Housing and taxes are the biggest levers, but not the only ones.
Car insurance tends to run higher in Florida than upstate New York, though often comparable to city rates. Utilities spike in summer when air conditioning runs around the clock — budget for this honestly, especially if you're coming from an apartment where heat and electric were baked into rent.
Groceries, restaurants, and everyday goods are generally comparable to New York suburban pricing — not Midwest cheap, but noticeably less than Manhattan, where every restaurant check carries embedded commercial rent costs.
Childcare and private school tuition vary. South Florida has a robust network of Jewish day schools — particularly in Aventura, Hollywood, and Boca Raton — so if Jewish education is a priority, the options are strong and the competition in the market keeps quality high. Healthcare costs depend heavily on your life stage and employer benefits, but Florida's large hospital networks — Memorial, Baptist, Cleveland Clinic outposts — provide solid coverage across most South Florida communities.
South Florida is not one place. Community fit matters as much as price per square foot.
Aventura is the front-runner for Brooklyn and Queens families who want to land somewhere that already feels like home. There's a large, established Ashkenazi and Sephardic Jewish community, multiple shuls across denominations, strong kosher restaurant and grocery infrastructure, and an eruv. It functions, in many ways, like a warmer version of Rego Park or Flatbush — without the winters.
Hallandale Beach sits just north of Aventura and offers slightly more affordable entry points, particularly in the condo market. Many families buy here first, then move up as they settle.
Hollywood has seen a significant influx of younger New York families, drawn by its more affordable detached homes, proximity to both Fort Lauderdale and Miami, and a growing Jewish infrastructure.
Boca Raton attracts families looking for top-rated public schools and more land. The Jewish community in Boca — particularly in West Boca — is large, well-organized, and multigenerational.
Sunny Isles Beach offers luxury high-rise living close to Bal Harbour, with an oceanfront community that has a distinctly Russian-Jewish and Israeli flavor. Dense, international, and walkable.
Surfside is small and walkable, with one of the most established Modern Orthodox communities in the state — institutions that rival much larger enclaves elsewhere in the country.
Worth saying clearly: the financial math is compelling, but moving to Florida doesn't resolve every cost pressure.
If you're carrying New York debt — credit, tuition loans, a high mortgage on a city property — you carry that south with you. If your family's income depends on New York-specific industries and you haven't yet secured remote work or Florida-based employment, the tax savings are real but partial.
The families who benefit most are those who own a New York property they can sell at strong value, have portable income (remote work, retirement, business), and have a clear community anchor in their destination neighborhood.
The honest answer to how much a New York family can save moving to Florida is: it depends on your income, your current housing situation, your life stage, and where in Florida you land. But for most middle-to-upper-income New York families with portable income and real estate equity, the combined savings on taxes and housing are genuinely significant — often life-changing on a multi-year horizon.
The families who navigate this best are the ones who work with people who've done it themselves. The Neuman Group is a South Florida real estate team made up of former New Yorkers who specialize in helping Brooklyn and NYC families find the right community fit, not just the right address — which is a meaningfully different thing when you're also relocating your schools, your shul, and your whole family's daily life.
Do the specific math with a Florida CPA before you commit. Walk the neighborhoods in person. Talk to families who made the move two or three years ago — the people already living in Aventura or Hollywood who came from Flatbush or Crown Heights will tell you more than any spreadsheet.
---
To benefit from Florida's no-income-tax status, you need to establish domicile — Florida driver's license, voter registration, and a genuine intent to make it your primary home. Many families maintain a New York pied-à-terre, but the primary residence designation must be clearly documented to withstand any scrutiny from New York state.
For most NYC families with owned property and stable income, yes — particularly when you combine the elimination of state and city income tax, far more housing space per dollar, and the Homestead Exemption on property taxes. The main cost additions are higher summer utility bills and car-related expenses. The net result for most families is meaningfully positive.
Aventura, Boca Raton, Surfside, and Hollywood all have large, active Jewish communities with shuls across denominations, kosher options, Jewish day schools, and established eruvin. The best fit depends on your observance level, family stage, and whether you prioritize walkability, space, or community density.
Florida does not tax retirement income of any kind — including pensions, IRA and 401(k) distributions, and Social Security benefits. For retirees and early retirees relocating from New York, this is one of the most immediate and substantial financial advantages of the move.
Many families benefit from renting for six to twelve months in their target neighborhood before buying. It lets you road-test the community, understand the micro-differences between areas, and shop without time pressure. That said, families with a clear community anchor — an established shul, family already nearby, kids enrolled in a specific school — often buy directly and do just fine.
← Back to The Neuman Group